Guide To Research And Writing In Music History Do not fall into the entice of reading and reading to keep away from getting started on the writing. After you've the bulk of information you would possibly need, start writing. You can fill within the smaller gaps of your research extra successfully later. Use the footnotes and bibliographies of common background books as well as reference aids to lead you to special studies. If Carleton doesn't have the books or sources you need, try ordering by way of the library minitex. So glad I gave this task to someone so professional. Our service comes with a cash-back assure, however our work is so good you won't really need this option. If there is a specialized bibliography on your topic, you'll certainly want to consult that as nicely, however these are often a bit dated. If you don't already have a basic background in your subject, get the most recent good basic supply on the subject and read it for common orientation. On the idea of that reading formulate as clearly focused query as you can. You ought to generally discuss together with your professor at that point whether or not your query is a feasible one. Writing an excellent task isn't troublesome should you observe the right steps. Make positive you pick a relevant subject and it is possible for you to to submit a superb task. ”, you comply with our terms of service and privateness policy. We’ll sometimes ship you promo and account related emails. As you have record of sources prepared, make sure that they come from dependable sources or checked by your faculty professor, if required. Likewise, accurate formatting style is important for good grades. Since that is what will make the heart of any written assignment, give you completely different variations of thesis as it will be simpler to adjust it later when you have body paragraphs prepared. On the opposite hand, those that wish to try to write the papers themselves canget a research paper written for you as well by working with an individual who is an professional in that field. This is where selecting related bits of data makes it crucial before define is composed. Since majority of fine analysis assignments embrace 3-5 physique paragraphs, start by checking whether or not you may find at least 5 key ideas to put in writing about when wanting by way of existing concepts. An example, when writing about Pearl Harbor, key rule is to outline thesis assertion, proceed with arguments or assumptions that constitute physique paragraphs. We don't copy, we create anew – every project begins with authentic ideas and ends with a cheerful customer. But how are you going to choose an fascinating topic for your task? Finding an excellent topic can be annoying and is why plenty of students are involved about finding one of the best tips about writing a historical paper. By clicking “Order now”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. There’s no substitute for a second set of eyes, which is why you need to rely on essay enhancing by dependable professionals. It is critical that in your new draft your paragraphs start with subject sentences that identify the argument you will be making within the particular paragraph . The particular person steps in your argument should be clearly mirrored within the subject sentences of your paragraphs . Next, you shouldn’t depend on conventional sources. You ought to be capable of discover topics from a different angle. Last, you must ensure the subject personally pursuits you. You can by no means end a great academic task when you don’t like the subject you might be writing about. First, you'll have to focus on your school or faculty class’ topic. General subjects like Ancient Greek History, American History or music history paper subjects could be the define you're employed with.
0 Comments
Top Research Paper Writing Courses Online One extra cause to decide on us amongst rivals is our Money-Back Guarantee. Even in case if our writers fail to fulfill your expectations, which is nearly unimaginable, you will not regret turning for us. A free inquiry lets you affirm that a professional writer is out there to begin working on your assignment. All you need is to fill out the brief type beneath, and we will contact you with a quote and availability of an appropriate writer. I even have been working along with your service for sometime now and I like it. Working two jobs and faculty was getting the best of me. Paperell has made the ordering of assignments fast and streamlined. Besides, we aim at providing the proper paper on the first try, but if you nonetheless feel unhappy with the work, you can get free revisions. We additionally offer the most effective safety standards when you want to buy analysis papers from us. Our payment info is encrypted and we additionally don’t retailer our shopper’s personal data or accomplished works. No one will ever find out you ordered a paper on-line and the content you obtain will be yours. You may be nervous whether or not you will get a specific topic given to you by your professor carried out. You can relaxation simple figuring out that we will cover all kinds of task and tasks. Whether you’re buying research paper for a case research, guide evaluate, statistics, economics, and many more courses, we’ve received you lined. Consultants from our assist group will gladly accept your order and inform you about the details of our writing, delivery and cost procedures. ii The firm doesn't condone plagiarism, copyright infringement or any type of educational dishonesty. All provided sample providers should solely be used for reference purposes whereas being cited properly. An introduction catches the attention of your reader. You can talk along with your author throughout the method. You have the choice to go away detailed instructions or to simply present a topic and let the author work out the details. Impress your professor with a properly-thought-out research paper written for you. So, let your analysis paper be an instance of your capability to conduct a deep, thorough investigation of a topic or issue and to reveal your writing proficiency. Make use of a research paper with a coherent structure. Also, they need to present their ideas in a logical, coherent method. Provide all details and we’ll ensure to follow the instructions. Although the order kind is detailed, it’s nonetheless pretty simple to complete. This is but a glimpse of the disparate fields of research that our writers are specialists in. Additionally, analysis work assist for various sorts can be obtainable, together with analytical, argumentative, experimental, and plenty of others. Get your free quote before placing the order if you want to receive further information. We support our service with a 24/7 customer care heart staffed with reside brokers — not bots — on the cellphone and via online stay chat. So should you assume that I need assistance to write my research paper, you must come to Paperell, ask for assist, and get quick help. Your particulars usually are not shared with anyone however the writers. Ultius is the trusted provider of content solutions for consumers all over the world. Connect with nice American writers and get 24/7 assist. They are experts in this kind of document and need to help you succeed. You ought to flip for reasonable essay assist from us as a result of we offer solely 100% unique papers which are cited correctly. We know that plagiarism can result in terrible consequences, so we by no means rewrite and resell our papers. We assure that you'll obtain a totally unique paper from us that's written from scratch in accordance with your particular person instructions. We’ll need your directions on the research project. Maybe it’s a broad theme and you want the author to decide on a particular topic?
9/24/2020 0 Comments Hiccupping, Itching And SneezingHiccupping, Itching And Sneezing One of his adventures via time positioned him into essentially the most unique predicament – waking up a special age everyday. Therefore, it's at all times clever to check together with your doctor in case your hiccup lasts longer than 48 hours. Similar to the above, this increases the carbon dioxide ranges and so much less diaphragm spasm. A hiccup happens when certain triggers causes the diaphragm to move the wrong method during inhalation. Instead of moving downwards, the diaphragm pushes upwards as you breathe in. As Self Appointed President of the Pajama Club, she spends most of her time in her jammies enjoying fake as kitty cat “Callie.” Wear your jammy-jams to the Inventionasium and join her membership! She loves signing up new members- particularly after they show up of their pajamas. Hiccups work primarily the same way - a shock to your system bumps the hiccup CPG into its lively state. Simply ready will often be sufficient that the bout stops on its own because the CPG randomly returns to its resting state. But should you're impatient, any variety of hiccup cures that rely on bodily or chemical shocks to your system could do the trick instantly. Often in physics we see methods that have been knocked from their ground states to larger states, which spontaneously drop back some random amount of time later. If you don't feel like ready, hitting a system with another shock that's similar to the one which bumped it out of its floor state often knocks it back. This abruptly modifications the way air moves within the windpipe and the result's a hiccup. Some people would possibly prefer Fesmire's therapeutic massage, however I'm guessing that most individuals would select the orgasm stimulation to tickle their vagus nerves and kick the hiccup CPG back to its resting mode. However, I might have failed the every day problem, however not all was lost! Next door is a Bowen Island Bakery and so they will provide you with bread in a paper bag, so that's a good start. The extra cash you've, the more bullets you possibly can shoot. Take nine or 10 quick sips in a row from a glass of water. When you’re gulping a drink, rhythmic contractions of the esophagus override spasms of the diaphragm. If this doesn’t work, place a single layer of paper towel over the top of a glass, then drink through the towel. You’ll should “pull” even more durable with your diaphragm to suck up the water. Maybe someone else hiccuping can get you laughing. Altering your respiratory cycle, which may calm your diaphragm down. Possibilities include respiration into a paper bag, pulling your knees to your chest and leaning ahead, ingesting water from the opposite aspect of a glass whereas bending over, or holding your breath. If you do maintain your breath, just remember to don’t do this indefinitely. In the case of an electron in a higher orbit around its atom, this is known as stimulated emission. It takes a photon to get the electron up there within the first place, and one other photon can induce the electron to fall again to the ground state instantly as a substitute of randomly. Personally, I suppose Fesmire's discovery is a a lot cleverer way to stimulate the nerve. It's the primary day of July, and I simply encountered my first hiccup. Desperately feeling like some Korean japchae, which requires the oh-so-delicious candy potato noodles. I don't know the place you can buy these so they do not come packaged in plastic. If you will drive, operate a mix harvester, or do something that requires good focus and coordination, the most effective factor to do is not drink in any respect. Even if it means, heaven forbid, revealing your actual sober character at a celebration or on a date, it is not worth the threat to try to time your private alcohol clearance exactly. I walked up to Harris Farm to get some bread as a result of I know they promote the reusable bread swags there. Unfortunately by the point I arrived the bread window had closed. The trick here is you have to come early within the morning if you want to bag your own bread. When I do use paper to take notes nowadays, I usually do use a pencil. It's funny, as a result of it was a fairly hard adjustment from a pen (if I do say so myself!) There's something concerning the good smooth lines of a top-notch fountain pen. But my favourite bag of all time is a hand woven bag given to me by Wendy Marcus that got here from the Mosman Markets. I get stopped all the time to ask the place it's from. Comfort 10/10, capacity 10/10, style factors 15/10.
9/24/2020 0 Comments Introduction To Research PptIntroduction To Research Ppt Our research spans virtually all the major sub-fields of economics. Essay template examples, the way to annotate a book title in an essay? Whats a great app to put in writing essays hidden figures movie evaluation essay gujarati essay app. Research papers are revealed in the CNB Working Papers, CNB Research and Policy Notes and. Economic Research Southern Africa is a research programme which is. Your personal data will be used to help your expertise all through this web site, to manage entry to your account, and for other purposes described in our privateness coverage. Essay on political map of india why you need to be taught english essay tips on how to begin a persuasive essay ideas essay ban plastic to avoid wasting surroundings. We supply our students the flexibility to take faculty credit whereas in High School both saving them money and time in the future. The mission of Discovery Charter Preparatory School is to broaden entry to greater training. We present the skills students of all achievement levels might want to reach their highest academic potential. This workshop introduces important aspects of the American Psychological Association Style used to format analysis papers. The introductory material describes what APA Style is, why it's used, and who ought to use it. Essay on gst in india 200 words do we really need training to be successful essay. University of chicago essay examples on core Argumentative essay common my father day by day routine essay in english maza desh marathi essay spm essay a choice that changed my life. Dr. Jeffrey A. Edwards is Professor of Economics at North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University. He is the creator of dozens of peer-reviewed publications so far. An interdisciplinary initiative for researchers on the University excited about experimental and behavioural science with necessary implications for economics, psychology, administration, advertising and statistics. Our goal is to interact in revolutionary research that extends the frontiers of the self-discipline, contributing to a deeper understanding of how fashionable economies perform, and the way they'll adapt to future challenges. Our academics collaborate with organisations together with the Bank of England, worldwide and native governments, assume tanks and NGOs. They are sought-after in public service roles, frequently offering recommendation to parliamentary committees and serving on authorities advisory boards. When educational psychology graduate student Amber Zhang obtained her first writing assignment for a philosophy class, she found it tough to get ideas presented and onto paper. Describes the way to format lists within the text of APA papers. Provides models and examples for the part headers used to organize APA papers. Our analysis seeks to generate information that can be used to strengthen economies and profit societies around the globe. From migration and trade to worldwide improvement and stopping financial crises, we address a number of the most urgent issues of our time and supply recommendations to policymakers and different stakeholders. You additionally may profit from taking programs in Math similar to linear algebra and multivariable calculus. The overwhelming majority of papers are available on-line, the earliest of which is from 1975. If a paper is unavailable online, exhausting copies may be requested freed from cost.
9/23/2020 0 Comments Essay On My Christmas HolidayEssay On My Christmas Holiday Please observe that the variety of revisions is proscribed in case you have any additional instructions or pattern to observe. However, you've a possibility to contact your writer or assist group by way of cellphone or chat at any time. After that, place a deposit in your account which is able to solely be released to the author after the work is finished. Do you could have any difficulties guessing how precisely the finished project should look? We are glad to assist you with any specifications. In addition, we've special plagiarism checker instruments. This profit goes with all the opposite options you get for the worth. If you discover that old ideas do not match as well as you anticipated, you should cut them out or condense them. You may also find that new and well-suited concepts occurred to you during the writing of the primary draft — nows the time to make them a part of the paper. You also can acquire inspiration from different analysis. The discussion or recommendations sections of research papers usually include ideas for different particular subjects that require further examination. A analysis paper is a piece of academic writing that provides evaluation, interpretation, and argument based on in-depth independent analysis. It is our immense knowledge in a research paper business which enables us to give you useful recommendation every time! Besides, earlier than sending the finished order back to you, our dedicated experts will proofread the paper and make all the required corrections. As you'll be able to notice from the examples on our website, even the most complicated papers are excellent. Moreover, we shall be more than happy to give you a plagiarism report that may be sent to you once the paper is completed. Research writing help is an efficient instrument of a objective-focused scholar who needs more free time and better marks by losing much less time. Here’s a fast information on how to order research paper help safely on our site. Second, you have to understand the writing course of and observe it step-by-step. If you're dissatisfied, request a free revision or get your money back. Our writing experts will start responding within 1 minute to your request. Discuss all of the possible details directly with the author and negotiate the value. Get your writing task done in-time and based on the instructions. If you are glad with the outcomes, approve the project and the cost will be launched to the author. Just please keep in mind, that we now have a 14-day time frame for the reason that order is completed for submitting such requests free of charge. You should not worry about plagiarism since we assure the originality of the delivered paper. Our specialists write your papers from scratch and the level of plagiarism is at all times close to zero. If you don’t have access to a sure book, our database may store it. You are certainly aware of the truth that any paper has an compulsory ultimate date of submission, and if it is not completed due date, the instructor could not accept it. However, each scholar may face a scenario when she or he could merely overlook about some assigned task or sometimes combine up the deadlines. There is for positive a writer in our team ready to start out working instantly, be it day or evening. We'll be very happy to give you as many revisions as you need until you're fully satisfied with the standard of your paper.
9/21/2020 0 Comments Paper FormattingPaper Formatting Opponents claim this can cause college budgets to plummet, whereas advocates say it provides a greater schooling for children. This analysis paper analyzes the potential for both outcomes. The “Content” part is considered extraordinarily important when writing various types of educational and non-tutorial reviews. All forms of academic tasks require the addition of it within the fields of psychology, enterprise management, history, environmental sciences, and many others, and so forth. Our elite group of editing specialists has helped hundreds of academics, researchers, college students, and enterprise professionals improve their writing and achieve their goals. You ought to use the primary-individual point of view when speaking about your personal research, however ought to mainly give attention to the research itself and never the researcher. A good rule of thumb is to check with the scientific method when writing your project. It will assist you to method it with a methodically sound construction. The scientific technique additionally helps you create the methodology for your main analysis. Use only one area after a interval in the physique of the paper. This is a professional paper instance from the seventh Edition of the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association. This is a student paper instance from the seventh Edition of the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association. Many areas require every pupil to add text to their educational paperwork. Thus, you, any reader, will be able to discover a convenient search course of they are interested in reading. You can buy a splendid analysis proposal online so as to show your instructor that your project deserves attention. You will turn into a revered and excellent student with us. Ultius is the trusted provider of content solutions for customers around the globe. APA guidelines encourage this inclusion but don't require it. in parentheses at the end of the quoted textual content. Let us help maximize your writing impression at present. as nicely if the paraphrased information is located on a specific page of the unique textual content. Connect with great American writers and get 24/7 assist. Connect with knowledgeable author by inserting your first order. The entire order process takes roughly 5 minutes and we normally match you with a author inside a number of hours. It concludes your paper, tying your results together with the overall story your paper is attempting to tell. You can slim your introduction by evaluating the importance of the paper's subject, earlier conclusions, areas of expertise and focus, and the primary findings of the analysis. An experimental report outlines and explains your own original analysis based mostly on an experiment you designed and carried out. It often contains the same main sections used within the literature review plus supplemental information explaining your outcomes. Your paper’s largest section will be the major content, divided into several subsections. U.S. Secretary of Education Elizabeth “Betsy” DeVos is the Secretary of Education is understood for her ideas regarding college funding. DeVos advocates for constitution faculty preferential treatment and voucher applications designed to allow dad and mom more choices. An summary is a concise summary of the key factors of your analysis and introduces the thesis assertion. Abstracts aren't always needed but are really helpful by APA tips. They present the reader with a first look and gain understanding of what they're about to learn. Voice and perspective are essential in APA writing. Note that the citation marks surround the text only, and never the parenthetical citation. Writing a analysis proposal is not any much less important than preparing a analysis paper. A good research proposal enhances success on your project.
What Are The List Of Websites For Free Access Of Research Paper? We are here to assist, and we provide that assist with none judgment. We know that it isn’t lazy or apathetic students who ask for assist. Using different coloured markers, draw a star next to the day you’re beginning the project and a star next to the day that the paper is due. Cross off any days you won’t be capable of work on the report due to different commitments, then count the remaining days until the due date. Divide the variety of workdays into three-week sections. And pondering should not be normal, full of stereotypes, but authentic, sometimes even paradoxical. It should divulge to the reader all the nuances of human relationships, life’s problems and the very essence of man. Patient attitude just isn't solely in regards to the creative course of itself. A bibliography is usually a part of a research report — and if it isn’t, including one will impress the trainer. Group the various ideas into five, six, or seven topics that you just need to cowl in your report. For a paper on a whale, for instance, you may include Physical Features, Food, Mating and Offspring, Location and Migration, Endangered or Not, Interesting Facts. If your paper meets your authentic instructions but you continue to have any recommendations for it, you will need to pay a bit more for such a revision. Working with one shoe box at a time, lay all of the cards on a table, paper-clip like info together, and number the packet of cards. For instance, beneath “Food,” you might group together the information about krill and the small fish that orcas eat near the surface of the ocean. Another grouping may be larger fish that orcas devour and how deep they need to dive to hunt them. On a separate piece of paper, write down a listing of the books/authors and supplies you used. With us, you possibly can sleep peacefully and not worry a few a number of-hour project. We will do every little thing in time on your peace of mind and a great result. The writer should remember that their work ought to at all times have an idea. We assure the originality and individuality of each project. Even in the shortest possible time, we do not enable ourselves to plagiarize. After writing the fabric, we take a look at it with special plagiarism and literacy applications. One thing that we do to assist break down a few of these obstacles is to supply up some reductions to make our companies extra accessible. If you need help with a analysis or term paper for any purpose, don’t be nervous. But workers can get the job carried out as quickly as possible by adjusting to your phrases. Even if you should write a job in a few hours, we will try to bring it to life. In truth, it is the college students who care that ask for assist. The company guarantees you continued help as much as the time you submit your work. We understand that there are attainable adjustments after the writing course of, so we execute them if essential. The deadline for finishing an essay in our firm is three to 6 hours depending on the requirements and dimension. If the project is about, say, whales, choose a sort that interests you — the humpback, the orca, the blue? It’s simpler to write down about something that you simply find intriguing or that you simply already know something about. Okay, you’re about a month into the college year, and you’re getting the hang of the new routine, new lecturers, and totally different lessons. You’re doing okay — maintaining with the math evaluations and studying assignments. But now your instructor throws you the curve ball you knew was coming — the primary long research paper.
How Long Does It Take To Write A A Thousand Word Essay? This time, look specifically for grammar and keyboard errors. If the thought of staring at your paper one more time makes your eyes glaze over, ask a good friend or relative to read it and supply constructive feedback. Some instructors provide you with ten weeks to finish a project, while others might allot a measly four. Plan backward from the day your paper is due and map out a schedule that allows you adequate time to finish. I spent plenty of time researching skilled writing corporations and I gotta say that PaperWritingPros.com kept popping out on the highest of the record. Fortunately, fashionable technology has made it a lot less so. You can simplify the method by merely using the proper tools that can assist you alongside the way in which. Before you possibly can form a thesis sentence, you should do the analysis to seek out out what is already in the existing physique of work. You must evaluate associated literature on the topic and cannot merely duplicate what others have already stated, even if it is in your individual phrases. Money-back guarantee Our transparent refund policy is used each time our clients aren't glad with the service they receive. More than 97% of our papers are delivered earlier than the deadline even if it equals to 4 hours. This guide from the OWL at Purdue might help you with formatting your paper, using in-text citations, creating the entries in your reference list, and using APA type in your writing. Use these links to help you cite your sources in your paper and on the references web page. I selected them to care for a recent project and man am I glad I did my research and found them. I will certainly be using you guys once more in the future, you just made the method so easy. I think it’s essential to mention how skilled PaperWritingPros.com is to work with. They had been really easy to communicate with, I got my paper on time, at an inexpensive value, and I was really impressed with the quality of work. You can get your research paper writing accomplished the onerous way, or you can make it straightforward on your self with any of these 7 digital instruments. For this purpose, you ought to be prepared for, not solely the proper tools for the job, but also the ideas of the way to write a paper. Nowadays the classical measurement of scientific success is based on the publication of peer-reviewed papers. The famous “publish or perish” phrase has become the unwritten rule that guides each scientist because the starting of the career. Below are 113 good research subjects that will help you get you started in your paper. Usually, scientists are mechanically drawn to the outcomes but scientific information can solely be accepted as reality as soon as it has been replicated. To guarantee proper data validation , it's essential to have the methodology correctly written to the smallest element. Writing the methodology part of a paper is perhaps the most boring a part of the scientific writing course of. Check our continuation of providers webpage for updates associated to COVID-19. Notwithstanding this case, the strategies of a research paper are the most important content material. Don’t know how to avoid plagiarism when paraphrasing? Contact us by way of Messenger at any time of the day or night time, and our pros will help you incorporate the primary concepts of the writer or supply into your paper. o make sure that every facet of your paper helps your thesis statement and that the paper's organization is coherent. Outlines might seem like extra work, however they will make paper writing easier and extra efficient. The trick is determing when and tips on how to use outlines so that they function a device to help rather than hinder you. If you like outlines, you may create a top level view earlier than writing and then update it throughout the writing course of. The Writing Center, located in ECS 122D, offers one-to-one consultations and may help college students throughout any stage of the writing process. We've organized them into ten classes to make it simpler to seek out the type of analysis paper topics you're in search of. Take a step in the direction of your greatest academic aim - contact our group of specialists. Native English speakers from the UK, USA, Australia, and Canada will provide you with an beautiful piece of writing that meets your orders requirements. Before you hand in your paper, return by way of it again to catch any errors. If nothing else, use any of the citation checkers to give yourself a break. No one cares the way you created your reference pages and citations, anyway, as long as it follows the correct format. To say that analysis paper writing is tense is placing it mildly.
9/17/2020 0 Comments Essay Writing ServiceEssay Writing Service We assure to deliver 100% unique customized writing with out errors and plagiarisms. If you need help with paper, our ideas and methods will make your writing a whole lot simpler. the textual content could be revised as many instances as it is needed. The client could ask the author to add some info or to specific the textual content sentence in other way or change the closing paragraph. Proper prioritization, nicely-designed paragraphs and paragraphs in English - without english paper writing help right here cannot do. After all, plenty of work may be misplaced solely because you haven't correctly issued the doc itself. Then try the testimonials section of our website. You have the likelihood to vary the dissertation as many occasions as you need. When someone starts working with us, he has to supply us with all of the professor’s instructions and requirements that we should always follow. And all completed duties are written due to really helpful tutorial requirements. Even greater than scandal or a shoddy biographer, a author’s sheer quotability can assure an uneasy afterlife. Lorde’s strains ring like mantras, all sturdy cadences and neon warnings. If you have requested graphs, statistics tables and so on, these shall be included within the paper. You can select the type of referencing which you like; please click on the Referencing tab to learn extra about this. Yes, you possibly can maintain observe of the progress through your personal management panel. Her notion of self-care as “political warfare,” as she described it after her second most cancers prognosis, has been snatched up as a generic wellness credo. Usually the completed paper might be sent to you as an MS Word doc. Then, choose the ideas that enchantment to you essentially the most and that you can expand into an argument that will capture the reader’s consideration. Develop a draft of your paper after which let it set for a while. Next, have a look at it with fresh eyes and start to craft it into a well-organized, properly cited draft. Finally, proofread the whole paper a minimum of once before submitting it to your teacher. Yet, maintaining contact along with your author is the most efficient method to obtain dependable info with regard to your order progress. You can talk with the writer instantly, by way of the control panel. Our 100% buyer satisfaction coverage guarantees you that you could be request as many revisions as you find it necessary. All texts are necessarily checked for plagiarism, however pressing translations and help with an essay are also obtainable in certain sections of the portal. Help with an essay is now not an issue, it is only essential to entrust the work to actual professionals from the textual content. The work necessities of, for instance, a University Commission are too high. This paper will assist me lots to complete my theses research. We have a strict software process for our author and inspire them to work underneath high standards. This contains inventive and plagiarism free writing, with good command of English. Still, regardless of how well we describe our web site, utilizing any kind of service for the first time is a chance. We utilize reliable fee techniques, and we have a cash-again assure, so your cash is all the time secure. Moreover, if your accomplished paper just isn't fairly what you anticipated, then we will revise it for free. The key factors in writing any sort of paper are to research the subject of your selection after which to investigate the acquired knowledge. Based in your preliminary analysis, brainstorm for ideas and jot them down.
Effects of Copyright on the Consumption Music The aim of this dissertation is to understand the effects of copyright on the consumption and acquisition of music online. With a focus on Feels Like Free services such as Spotify as well as illegal file sharing services, research into the copyright issues surrounding the debate present a picture of how music is being consumed at present. Building on notable works and theories of research in the area {} the dissertation supplies evidence supporting the continuing dominance of labels as right-holders in the new digital era. With one-on-one interviews with emerging artists at the forefront of digital music as well as group interviews with consumers a convergence of opinion on key points provides an insight into the effectiveness of current digital music distribution services as well as the enforcement and enforceability of current copyright laws. Introduction This dissertation focusses on the challenges of distributing digital music in an era of unprecedented web use. Access to digital media is increasingly a part of peoples every day lives and the issues surrounding access to content and the legal implications therein are the subject of much debate. It is natural that the rights holders and their representatives would assume a position protecting their legal rights and the cases of pursuance of both individual and commercial rights infringers are well documented, however some say copyright law is dated (Negroponte, 1995) and beyond the task of policing the digital frontier of music distribution. This dissertation investigates the effect of copyright on audience and artist attitudes to digital music distribution in both legal and illegal forms. Using relevant literature and established studies it addresses the benefits of the chosen research for this investigation and provides results giving evidence for the various claims and counter claims made on both sides of the copyright argument. In doing so it is intended that my results will give a picture of current distribution methods and their ability to deal with copyright as well as rights holders ability to enforce it in an increasingly digitised age. By gathering evidence using one-to-one interviews with two emerging artists as well as consumer interviews conducted at group level I am able to establish the artists interaction with the process of copyright and the extent to which it alters their distribution of music whilst also engaging the audience in debate about their understanding and adherence to the existing issues surround accessing digital music. The involvement of both artist and audience provides a unique opportunity to pinpoint the present effect of the existing systems of music distribution and the copyright protection available. Digital Music Copyright At the crux of the debate surrounding digital music distribution is the issue of copyright and the infringement thereof. Arguments both for and against the current system of rights ownership and management are well documented and some clear division between the opinions of those who hope to gain capital from the ownership of rights and those who wish to produce and consume digital music is revealed. The representative bodies existing to support the rights of the artist , such as the BPI (British Phonographic Industry) and the RIAA (Recording Industry Association of America) have staunch views on the use of their intellectual property and defined by the BPI, copyright in its current form can be surmised as follows: Copyright is the foundations which the music business is built. In its simplest terms, it is a form of intellectual property and, as such, gives the creator or the owner/ author of that work exclusive rights over how it is published, distributed and adapted. (BPI [online] 2009) The collective gusto of the recording industry to enforce their stance on what they see as a critical issue to the music business has led to much bad publicity and a galvanisation of some copyright infringers as a group with a serious social point to make. Kembrew McLeod (2005) agrees that infringement of copyrighted material online presents a significant problem for the monopoly held by the industry giants, even going as far as to view this as a positive consequence of file sharing and distribution. Arguing in favour of a diminished corporate monopoly, McLeod uses examples of successes for smaller independent artists, helped in part by the evolution of media distribution methods available to cut out the middle-man. With both artist and audience interviews revealing a symRobhy for McLeodʼs statements, most participants demonstrated a sophisticated understanding of the possible advantages that new distribution methods offer smaller/less established artists, who often work outside of the boundaries of the established music industry. Williamson Cloonan (2007) accuse the BPI of blurring its distinction between the ‘interests of British record companies which it claims to represent with a wider definition of the ‘music business . The process of recording, distributing and marketing music is one element of the music industry but its inferred connection to grassroots music of all levels seems to be the bone of contention, as is borne out in my group research. The strength of language words and aggressive tone of both the RIAA and BPI in dealing with infingers, combined with the appropriation of the wider music industry for moral grounds (Williamson Cloonan, 2003, p. 305-7) adds to a misunderstanding regarding what exactly the music industry is and how it affects users access to media. There is an obvious disparity in opinion on either side of the debate surrounding copyright law, with the nature of what copyright represents and who it protects and particularly how it is relevant to new digital models of distribution and consumption open to much debate. These diverging opinions are likely to have an impact on how consumers and artists understand the issues within this field, and clearly how they relate and react to them. Media Access The history and development of studying audiences and their consumption habits is by now highly sophisticated and the subject of much debate and research. Using the work of others as a guide as well as theory and research my aim is to understand how audiences are accessing digital content and if their understanding of the legality of so doing , alters how they interact with the content. Longhurst (2007) observes that the most significant contemporary change to [music consumption] is coming through downloadability (p. 205). The pervasive nature of digital consumption in todays culture is displayed throughout both artist and audience responses showing high levels of use and understanding of the medium. An RIAA commissioned report (Siwek, 2007) carried out in the United States by the Institute for Policy Innovation (IPI) suggest that online copyright infringement costs the industry $12.5 billion annually(online). It is fair to assume the the access to both legal and illegal digital music is affect the industry greatly but these figures are open to criticism for there bias. The research of Huang (2005) into file sharing as a means of music consumption through group interviews of college students concludes that music file sharing is now a facet of music culture from a social perspective. My studies have some support for this claim with even artists describing extensive p2p use and one actively embracing it as a means of propagation of his material. Mascheroni et al (2008) conducted a comparable ethnographic study digital television consumption. The study concludes that young viewers are capable of defining their relationship with media based on present developments in the field rather than existing paradigms and traditions, and in doing so perhaps goes some way to explain the findings of Huangs research on college students. In similar ethnographic profiling Harwood (1997) compared television viewing Robterns of different aged groups, finding that decisions are representative of perceived Ê»social identityʼ. It is arguable that similar influences are at play in consumers interaction with digital music consumption and with the increasing convergence of digital content, user generated content, and the social influences aforementioned, copyright infringement and any repressions appear to have very marginal impact on consumption habits. Based on the highlighted works the interaction between consumers and the legal implications surrounding content access are likely to vary in line with social perception and experience led understanding of the field. The fact that the artists were so Robert about file sharing, their involvement with it and its potential for positive use, adds weight to the claim copyright regulations for digital music are past their prime and lacking in effectiveness. Unique Online Considerations Various possible explanations for the ways in which digital media access has changed consumption habits have been covered previously. Increased media access has inevitably led to increased temptation to use nodal connectivity for illegal file sharing, although if the enactment of this abuse is as widespread as the BPI and RIAA would like us to think is another matter. Borne out of this peer to peer system of file distribution new products are being brought to market that provide alternatives to illegal acquisition of content. Analysing the manner in which consumers access content and services online has led to , sophisticated modEmmang of the accessibility and demand for said content and services. Andersonʼs (2006) presents a long tail model which serves as an example of such studies. The model refers to online commercial distribution with the most popular and commercial, products at one end of the graph with the highest volume of sales. The graph extends to illustrate the almost limitless potential for online sales in specialist or minority markets. Fig i. Long Tail Model (Anderson, 2006) Anderson further sets forth an opinion that the broadening of potential promotion and distribution online has increasingly opened up more possibilities for for both artists and consumers. Applying the long tail theory, it is obvious that it proposes a different system of economics to the traditional retail sector. Adding to this the obvious advantages of products being available around the clock, often irrespective of regional restrictions and the idea of a new economic model is further strengthened. The ability to cover areas of minuscule interest with little additional overheads enables retailers to offer huge depth of choice as well as broadening the idea of ownership of content through streaming.. Clearly the economics of online commerce are very different to the traditional model, however the rules of engagement surrounding copyright are expected to fit both models. two is different, yet the laws of copyright remain the same. Illegal sharing of content is viewed as an infringement of rights and therefore a form of theft as attested by the RIAA. The case that eventually closed the late nineties file sharing platform Napster, as detailed first by Merriden (2001) and then Menn (2003) illustrates the ramifications and interest in the first high-profile case of file sharing. Speaking of Napster Wall states; The record companies proposed that the Napster system ripped off artists and would kill music, while they made the legal argument that Napster encouraged the infringement of copyrights they held. Napster countered by arguing that members of Napster were making fair non-commercial use of the rights already assigned with the original sale of the record that had been converted into mp3 files. (Wall 2003, p223) Continuing where the Napster litigation left off, cases between the industry and p2p networks are still widespread today, showing that the industry has moved on little in the intervening years. The Swedish prosecution and proposed imprisonment of the creators of infamous file sharing tracker The Pirate Bay (Johnson Kiss, 2009) is perhaps the highest profile case today and could be seen as the modern Napster. In an attempt to bolster the music industries grasp on digital distribution a number of new models have been brought to market., Many mobile phone operators worldwide now offer unlimited music bundles with cell contracts and the emergence of streaming services mentioned such as Last.fm and Spotify, are seen in the group interviews to have a positive influence on peoples adherence to copyright. Gerd Leonhard (with Kusek 2005 2008) is describes these services as Ê»feels like free.ʼ Advertising and premium service upgrades present the creates potential for capitalisation of music. Spotify has been a particular success in Europe, with the BBC reporting figures that already 5% of its users have upgraded to a premium service, giving it some 320,000 users paying £10 per month for its full offering (BBC, 2010, online). This small percentage provides and annual turnover in the region of £38,400,000 excluding additional revenue provided by advertising, proving that Spotify is a serious force in the online distribution business without even launching fully in the United States. By looking at audience habits and interaction with both copyright and media we can see that the new media model and the traditional approach to distributing music are increasingly unable to keep up with the consumer driven demand for online services, leaving companies such as Spotify to move in and become a type of new music industry for the 21st century. The difficulty inherent to their role is that the copyright for the material they wish to distribute is often owned by one of their more traditional predecessors. Methodology In this chapter I offer justification for the effectiveness of my methods for the collection of audience and artist responses to their interaction with digital music copyright. I use two groups of participants; one younger (16- 25) as well as a group from an older demographic of consumers (40-65) with both groups being representative of consumers as well as two individuals representative of artists. As this study represents a small cross section of the many people who are involved in roles as both consumer and artist definitive conclusions solely gathered from my findings alone are difficult to ascertain. The value however, of conducting the comparative interview types, is the provided overview of responses, and how they interplay with the core arguments surrounding the debate. Work by Huang (2005) and Macheroni et al (2008) would suggest that younger audiences are less concerned about the implications of peer to peer sharing and thus more likely to use the distribution method. Using relative methods I build upon their work, highlighting and supporting claims by providing complimentary evidence and similar findings. Huangʼs (2005) use of groups interviews highlighted specific areas of interest with direct interaction with audience members, whilst Mascheroniʼs (2008) research adopted ethnographic studies of online, as well as off line interaction in a more one to one manner. Due to the nature of copyright interaction online ethnographic study of users could be applied to researching users of file sharing services. The problem with this is the anonymity in this type of cinteraction, discussed by Watt, Lea and Spears (2002). Although there is potential for some light to be shed on how audiences share music online, it would be difficult to rationalise the reasons for this activity, providing little evidence to illuminate the reader on audience behaviour. My own studies, made use of extensive one on one interviews allowing unsigned artists a mouthpiece within the debate. The benefit of exposing the artists to the one on one interview process was expected to be a greater understanding and experience of copyright yielding technical data on the subject. This was then coupled with group based research. With guidance from Bertrand and Hughes (2005, p81), the group interviews, were expected to benefit from inter-participant discussion allowing some involved to make up in shortfalls of technical knowledge. As a well established means of audience research, group interviews can help garner natural responses from participants. It must always be considered however that these discussions do not take place in unmonitored environments and so must be viewed as having the potential to be polluted by the participants knowledge that what is being said is also being recorded. A particularly pertinent issue given the legal climate surrounding the issues covered. The legal aspect of my research may encourage participants to shy away from full, Robert answers, however the focus group environment should also foster greater candour and less inherently solicited responses than that of one on one interviews for instance (Boubour 2007) although the combination of the two means of study should have a balancing effect on the results. Research Findings Here I present the findings of my primary research investigating the interplay between copyright issues and digital music consumption. The material put forward here is the product of the two group interviews and two individual interviews with consumers and artists respectively. The discussions centred around the same key themes including the participants access to and use of digital music as well as attitudes and understanding of the related legal issues. Of particular importance for my study are responses they may have relevance towards legal the constraints and considerations surrounding the notion of digital music access. Providing the the structural basis of this chapter my aim is to discover any visible Robterns between the responses of the two types of interviewee. Consumption Listening Habits: The primary question for the interviews is one of use and involvement in digital music. It is essential to establish the extent, if any, to which the interview subjects interact with digital music content, irrespective of its origin. The following section examines participant music consumption routines and in particular, digital music consumption habits. Based on their replies, I address the stereotype that older audiences are less willing and able to undertake interaction with new delivery methods whilst isolating comparisons between the groups in other forms of music consumption. On broaching the subject of use of digital music with the older group, it was clear that most participants were involved and responsive to the means of content distribution. Many of the group cited the iPhone or iPod as an influence on their ease of access and enjoyment of digital music, proving Apple have a huge say in how this market is set to develop. either using mp3 players or their mobile phone to consume digital music. When the group was asked if they had access to a digital music player the response was as follows, Howard: Of course Iʼve had mp3 phones for a good 5 years now and players for a bit longer. Dominic: Yeah me too I would say, not the players but the phones, I use an iPhone for everything now. Howard: I still use my player for jogging though, I dont like to be bothered by phone calls but I still want my music with me. Most made some use of access to digital music on a regular basis. This helps to dispel the myth of a generation gap regarding digital media use as alluded to in the work of Mascheroni et al (2008). Although this establishes a commonality in usage of devices we are yet to establish meaningful connections between access and consumption habits. In the older group. The concept of digital music consumption representing the mainstay of their listening habits produced varied responses. For the older group the response was as follows: Dominic: For the car or the house I spose real music, sorry I should say CDs and stuff I spose, real music is normally what I go for. Robert: Yeah the same really. This is similar to the attitudes of both artists interviewed. Biometrix: Yeah its really all about vinyl for me but that normally means I have to rip the vinyl if I want to listen to it on my phone or anything like that Gecko: I collect all sorts of CDs and records, when we go on tour I normally come back with a pile of discs Ive either bought or been given. With the artists and the older audience still actively engaged in the acquisition and collation of music it is clear that there is still a space for tangible products within the music industry. Such observations are notably absent when dealing with the younger of the group studies. In this group there was evidence of a fractured landscape of media access with no commonly held method of consuming music. Youtube, Spotify and Soundcloud provide a number of feels like free options for home use along with the ubiquitous iPod/Phone, however the access to music was overwhelmingly digital amongst this group. It can be said that both groups access digital content in a number of ways, with the younger group being more selective and more aware of different delivery methods, perhaps indicated by the greater disparity in the services and methods of consumption they chose. Within this younger group, extensive different ways of acquiring digital music were referenced, including demonstrable evidence of Leonhardʼs (2008) Ê»feels like freeʼ streaming services such as Spotify and Last.fm. The following extract is taken from the opening stages of the younger focus group; MarT: Spotify, mainly. Youtube too, but there is much less music on there now and when you find something you like it gets deleted after a while for copyright stuff. Spotify have made it so easy and if they have pretty much everything so you can just go there, and if you canʼt find it aint on Spotify there might be a live version or something on Youtube but the quality is always ropey. The only bad thing about Spotify is that you get ads but its still free and its much safer than downloading audio files. Steve: Everything is so joined up on Spotify, like suggested artists and playlists and stuff, I spose its similar on Youtube, you can spend hours exploring. Claire: And you dont have to buy anything or give your card details over. Similarly both artists are avid users of Spotify amongst other streaming services: Gecko: I know the money is peanuts for getting played on there but it makes you accessible to so many people, some of them dont have enough money to pay for your album or your mp3 or whatever but the fact that they can still access it is important to grow as an artist. Its like playing a gig and barely making the petrol money to get home. We all do it but some of us are a bit more relaxed about the good it does for us. Biometrix: I use Spotify all the time, really its stopped me stealing a lot of music really. Its so much easier than actually downloading something so normally I just do that because I cant be bothered finding what I want and then waiting on it to arrive on my computer. Clearly Spotify offers an innovative model that can fit into both of Myškaʼs (2009) subscription service model categories. A monthly fee can be paid to allow listeners to enjoy uninterrupted music without advertising and also allow access to feature rich content such as mobile streaming and offline listening, as well as Leonhards (2009) Ê»feels like freeʼ model that is funded by advertising. Of the myriad methods of media access identified, use of Web 2.0 music consumption models such as Spotify demonstrates a fall in favour of traditional peer to peer networks, contrary to the testaments of the recording industry (Siwek, 2007.) This goes some way to enforce the claims of Leonhard (2009) that these new, lawful access streams provide an attractive alternative to illegal downloading and also allay industry concerns about copyright protection. The interview subjects also cited the simplicity of these new methods in allowing them to locate music without the extensive searching that is commonplace with peer to peer access to media. Engagement with File Sharing: In this section, we assess the subjects involvement with the file sharing. I present rationalisation of the participants use or otherwise of file sharing networks and investigate their understandings and interactions with the legal ramifications of such actions. As the conversation developed, unexpectedly within the older group, many of the participants had used peer to peer services in the past, whilst perhaps their usage was limited, responses seemed mixed. Shaun: Iʼve used Megaupload in the past Yeah. Subscribed to that. We didnt download without our subscription, but now lapsed, I dont about the kids but yeah, Megaupload. I used to et a lot of other stuff there like films and ebooks so it was great. We can see that the participants have an understanding of file sharing as a concept, if not perhaps the finer points of nodal networking. There is an inference that by purchasing a subscription the subject considers themselves to have bought their downloads. This is however false and the subscription simply provides faster download speeds. The artists had a more sophisticated understanding of how rights related to downloading and sharing content, however it is notable that this greater insight did little to dissuade them from partaking in file sharing. Biometrix: Yeah I do download stuff, not as much as I used to but if theres something I cant find on Spotify or Soundcloud or that stuff then I will just go on a torrent site but I feel bad about it, I reckon, well I reckon because I think about what it would be like if the musicians were like me, just starting out or something. The guilt mechanism in this response shows a belief that the RIAA/BPI position is correct and that the copyright issues surrounding this kind of media access is universally illegal. This shows some support for the industry having a direct influence over peoples online interactions despite their diminished market share. One of the artists in particular also uses p2p sharing to promote and distribute their own material. Biometrix: I try to make a couple of free songs every month and put them on soundcloud for people to download. Its pretty much a thanks to all the people on Facebook, Soundcloud and Youtube who like my music and keep my profile hits high. I know theyre on the torrent sites but I dont mind, they were free anyway. This positive use of filesharing allows the artist greater exposure with virtual nil as an overhead, undercutting the top-heavy music industry and presenting the egalitarian model favoured by McLeod (2005). Responses to Legal Issues Industry Implications; This section aims to build on the responses in the previous section by filling out the subjects understanding of the legal issues involved with file sharing. Particularly noticeable in these answers is the difference between the artist and audience categories. As mentioned earlier there have been many examples of litigations against providers of p2p services, such as the media-circus trial of Ê»The Pirate Bayʼ founders. Whilst the audience groups had little knowledge of such cases the artists seemed far better versed in what was going on within the industry to shape the distribution of music. Biometrix: Yeah, Iʼve know a lot about it actually The pirate bay have been found guilty of copyright abuse and theyre appealing their jail term now I think. Its a pretty big deal, all of the big film companies have been after them. The site is still going though, so it doesnt seem to have done much good does it? Gecko: Pirate bay is huge. Its not just pirating things, they do all sorts, politics and freedom of speech stuff and all of that. I think it was started by activists but I dont know whos involved nowadays. As soon as something gets taken off it seems to come straight back up. Loads of people use it. Infringement and theft are put forwards by McLeod as tactics to enforce the monopoly of the recording industry. Of the subjects opinions on the significance file sharing has for the music industry, the various subjects displayed an array of responses. The following extracts are taken from the older subjects; Dominic: Small bands dont have a bean basically. Those are the people you are robbing off, not the execs or anything. Emma: They must be getting paid somehow, the music is still out there. Robert: But the money doesnt go to the band. This passage underlines the fact that members in this group believe that the majority of income for musicians, particularly less prolific artists, is provided by their record sales. This understanding of the revenue streams available to music industries also demonstrates a finely tuned understanding of what the Ê»music industryʼ entails. Williamson and Cloonanʼs (2007) arguments against the wide spread use of the term, based on my findings, suggest older generations are indeed more inclined to understand the term equating to the recording industry. The actions of the recording industries and the responses from audiences can be seen as an example of Michel de Certeauʼs idea of Ê»strategies and tacticsʼ (1984). The strategies of the power structures within the relationship, in this case, the industries retention of traditional retail models and the discourse that it equates to the music industry (BPI, 2009), in contrast to the tactics of audiences. This investigation finds between age demographics the response tactics identifiable and noticably different. The older group creates their own space through a sceptical approach to recording industry practices, methods of media access and opinion demonstrate stronger ties with the recording industry discourse crime and punishment. The both the artists and younger group members seemed much more separated from these established means of operation, shown in their symRobhy for file sharing, anti-corporate comments and reluctance to trust established regulations regarding copyright infringement. Based on the findings outlined above, the suggestion is that audiences are highly aware that there are legal implications surrounding the sharing of files, but their opinions and responses to the validity of these implications are generationally split. The evidence provided by the younger demographic of both audience and artists provides support for the views of McLeod (2005) whereas the older group demonstrated a much more accepting response for the necessity of copyright legislation as a protection against theft. Applying music retail and commerce theories presented by Anderson (2006) and Dubber (2007), most of the participants appeared to be informed of the changes online distribution was experiencing, although there was rejection of the industrys reluctance to develop progressive content access agreements along with them. The divergence of opinion in the application of rights enforcement between the two groups adds weight to the arguments presented by Garofalo (2003), acting to set the balance between the two sides of the rights argument, preventing the financial exploitation of free music, whilst also managing a free channel of access to consumers. Conclusion It can be established from the results of my investigation that audience and artist opinions are divided on the justifications for rights protection and the enforcement thereof in relation to digital music access. Whilst there is clear evidence of a move towards digital media consumption, there is a distinct generational gap in the manner in which different age groups access music digitally. Older generations seem to fall into line with traditional models of product capitalisation, purchasing physical formats and viewing transgression of copyright online as theft. Younger subjects more immersed in digital media and having grown up during the internet gold rush have a far less strict attitude to the acquisit Effects of Copyright on the Consumption Music Effects of Copyright on the Consumption Music The aim of this dissertation is to understand the effects of copyright on the consumption and acquisition of music online. With a focus on Feels Like Free services such as Spotify as well as illegal file sharing services, research into the copyright issues surrounding the debate present a picture of how music is being consumed at present. Building on notable works and theories of research in the area {} the dissertation supplies evidence supporting the continuing dominance of labels as right-holders in the new digital era. With one-on-one interviews with emerging artists at the forefront of digital music as well as group interviews with consumers a convergence of opinion on key points provides an insight into the effectiveness of current digital music distribution services as well as the enforcement and enforceability of current copyright laws. Introduction This dissertation focusses on the challenges of distributing digital music in an era of unprecedented web use. Access to digital media is increasingly a part of peoples every day lives and the issues surrounding access to content and the legal implications therein are the subject of much debate. It is natural that the rights holders and their representatives would assume a position protecting their legal rights and the cases of pursuance of both individual and commercial rights infringers are well documented, however some say copyright law is dated (Negroponte, 1995) and beyond the task of policing the digital frontier of music distribution. This dissertation investigates the effect of copyright on audience and artist attitudes to digital music distribution in both legal and illegal forms. Using relevant literature and established studies it addresses the benefits of the chosen research for this investigation and provides results giving evidence for the various claims and counter claims made on both sides of the copyright argument. In doing so it is intended that my results will give a picture of current distribution methods and their ability to deal with copyright as well as rights holders ability to enforce it in an increasingly digitised age. By gathering evidence using one-to-one interviews with two emerging artists as well as consumer interviews conducted at group level I am able to establish the artists interaction with the process of copyright and the extent to which it alters their distribution of music whilst also engaging the audience in debate about their understanding and adherence to the existing issues surround accessing digital music. The involvement of both artist and audience provides a unique opportunity to pinpoint the present effect of the existing systems of music distribution and the copyright protection available. Digital Music Copyright At the crux of the debate surrounding digital music distribution is the issue of copyright and the infringement thereof. Arguments both for and against the current system of rights ownership and management are well documented and some clear division between the opinions of those who hope to gain capital from the ownership of rights and those who wish to produce and consume digital music is revealed. The representative bodies existing to support the rights of the artist , such as the BPI (British Phonographic Industry) and the RIAA (Recording Industry Association of America) have staunch views on the use of their intellectual property and defined by the BPI, copyright in its current form can be surmised as follows: Copyright is the foundations which the music business is built. In its simplest terms, it is a form of intellectual property and, as such, gives the creator or the owner/ author of that work exclusive rights over how it is published, distributed and adapted. (BPI [online] 2009) The collective gusto of the recording industry to enforce their stance on what they see as a critical issue to the music business has led to much bad publicity and a galvanisation of some copyright infringers as a group with a serious social point to make. Kembrew McLeod (2005) agrees that infringement of copyrighted material online presents a significant problem for the monopoly held by the industry giants, even going as far as to view this as a positive consequence of file sharing and distribution. Arguing in favour of a diminished corporate monopoly, McLeod uses examples of successes for smaller independent artists, helped in part by the evolution of media distribution methods available to cut out the middle-man. With both artist and audience interviews revealing a symRobhy for McLeodʼs statements, most participants demonstrated a sophisticated understanding of the possible advantages that new distribution methods offer smaller/less established artists, who often work outside of the boundaries of the established music industry. Williamson Cloonan (2007) accuse the BPI of blurring its distinction between the ‘interests of British record companies which it claims to represent with a wider definition of the ‘music business . The process of recording, distributing and marketing music is one element of the music industry but its inferred connection to grassroots music of all levels seems to be the bone of contention, as is borne out in my group research. The strength of language words and aggressive tone of both the RIAA and BPI in dealing with infingers, combined with the appropriation of the wider music industry for moral grounds (Williamson Cloonan, 2003, p. 305-7) adds to a misunderstanding regarding what exactly the music industry is and how it affects users access to media. There is an obvious disparity in opinion on either side of the debate surrounding copyright law, with the nature of what copyright represents and who it protects and particularly how it is relevant to new digital models of distribution and consumption open to much debate. These diverging opinions are likely to have an impact on how consumers and artists understand the issues within this field, and clearly how they relate and react to them. Media Access The history and development of studying audiences and their consumption habits is by now highly sophisticated and the subject of much debate and research. Using the work of others as a guide as well as theory and research my aim is to understand how audiences are accessing digital content and if their understanding of the legality of so doing , alters how they interact with the content. Longhurst (2007) observes that the most significant contemporary change to [music consumption] is coming through downloadability (p. 205). The pervasive nature of digital consumption in todays culture is displayed throughout both artist and audience responses showing high levels of use and understanding of the medium. An RIAA commissioned report (Siwek, 2007) carried out in the United States by the Institute for Policy Innovation (IPI) suggest that online copyright infringement costs the industry $12.5 billion annually(online). It is fair to assume the the access to both legal and illegal digital music is affect the industry greatly but these figures are open to criticism for there bias. The research of Huang (2005) into file sharing as a means of music consumption through group interviews of college students concludes that music file sharing is now a facet of music culture from a social perspective. My studies have some support for this claim with even artists describing extensive p2p use and one actively embracing it as a means of propagation of his material. Mascheroni et al (2008) conducted a comparable ethnographic study digital television consumption. The study concludes that young viewers are capable of defining their relationship with media based on present developments in the field rather than existing paradigms and traditions, and in doing so perhaps goes some way to explain the findings of Huangs research on college students. In similar ethnographic profiling Harwood (1997) compared television viewing Robterns of different aged groups, finding that decisions are representative of perceived Ê»social identityʼ. It is arguable that similar influences are at play in consumers interaction with digital music consumption and with the increasing convergence of digital content, user generated content, and the social influences aforementioned, copyright infringement and any repressions appear to have very marginal impact on consumption habits. Based on the highlighted works the interaction between consumers and the legal implications surrounding content access are likely to vary in line with social perception and experience led understanding of the field. The fact that the artists were so Robert about file sharing, their involvement with it and its potential for positive use, adds weight to the claim copyright regulations for digital music are past their prime and lacking in effectiveness. Unique Online Considerations Various possible explanations for the ways in which digital media access has changed consumption habits have been covered previously. Increased media access has inevitably led to increased temptation to use nodal connectivity for illegal file sharing, although if the enactment of this abuse is as widespread as the BPI and RIAA would like us to think is another matter. Borne out of this peer to peer system of file distribution new products are being brought to market that provide alternatives to illegal acquisition of content. Analysing the manner in which consumers access content and services online has led to , sophisticated modEmmang of the accessibility and demand for said content and services. Andersonʼs (2006) presents a long tail model which serves as an example of such studies. The model refers to online commercial distribution with the most popular and commercial, products at one end of the graph with the highest volume of sales. The graph extends to illustrate the almost limitless potential for online sales in specialist or minority markets. Fig i. Long Tail Model (Anderson, 2006) Anderson further sets forth an opinion that the broadening of potential promotion and distribution online has increasingly opened up more possibilities for for both artists and consumers. Applying the long tail theory, it is obvious that it proposes a different system of economics to the traditional retail sector. Adding to this the obvious advantages of products being available around the clock, often irrespective of regional restrictions and the idea of a new economic model is further strengthened. The ability to cover areas of minuscule interest with little additional overheads enables retailers to offer huge depth of choice as well as broadening the idea of ownership of content through streaming.. Clearly the economics of online commerce are very different to the traditional model, however the rules of engagement surrounding copyright are expected to fit both models. two is different, yet the laws of copyright remain the same. Illegal sharing of content is viewed as an infringement of rights and therefore a form of theft as attested by the RIAA. The case that eventually closed the late nineties file sharing platform Napster, as detailed first by Merriden (2001) and then Menn (2003) illustrates the ramifications and interest in the first high-profile case of file sharing. Speaking of Napster Wall states; The record companies proposed that the Napster system ripped off artists and would kill music, while they made the legal argument that Napster encouraged the infringement of copyrights they held. Napster countered by arguing that members of Napster were making fair non-commercial use of the rights already assigned with the original sale of the record that had been converted into mp3 files. (Wall 2003, p223) Continuing where the Napster litigation left off, cases between the industry and p2p networks are still widespread today, showing that the industry has moved on little in the intervening years. The Swedish prosecution and proposed imprisonment of the creators of infamous file sharing tracker The Pirate Bay (Johnson Kiss, 2009) is perhaps the highest profile case today and could be seen as the modern Napster. In an attempt to bolster the music industries grasp on digital distribution a number of new models have been brought to market., Many mobile phone operators worldwide now offer unlimited music bundles with cell contracts and the emergence of streaming services mentioned such as Last.fm and Spotify, are seen in the group interviews to have a positive influence on peoples adherence to copyright. Gerd Leonhard (with Kusek 2005 2008) is describes these services as Ê»feels like free.ʼ Advertising and premium service upgrades present the creates potential for capitalisation of music. Spotify has been a particular success in Europe, with the BBC reporting figures that already 5% of its users have upgraded to a premium service, giving it some 320,000 users paying £10 per month for its full offering (BBC, 2010, online). This small percentage provides and annual turnover in the region of £38,400,000 excluding additional revenue provided by advertising, proving that Spotify is a serious force in the online distribution business without even launching fully in the United States. By looking at audience habits and interaction with both copyright and media we can see that the new media model and the traditional approach to distributing music are increasingly unable to keep up with the consumer driven demand for online services, leaving companies such as Spotify to move in and become a type of new music industry for the 21st century. The difficulty inherent to their role is that the copyright for the material they wish to distribute is often owned by one of their more traditional predecessors. Methodology In this chapter I offer justification for the effectiveness of my methods for the collection of audience and artist responses to their interaction with digital music copyright. I use two groups of participants; one younger (16- 25) as well as a group from an older demographic of consumers (40-65) with both groups being representative of consumers as well as two individuals representative of artists. As this study represents a small cross section of the many people who are involved in roles as both consumer and artist definitive conclusions solely gathered from my findings alone are difficult to ascertain. The value however, of conducting the comparative interview types, is the provided overview of responses, and how they interplay with the core arguments surrounding the debate. Work by Huang (2005) and Macheroni et al (2008) would suggest that younger audiences are less concerned about the implications of peer to peer sharing and thus more likely to use the distribution method. Using relative methods I build upon their work, highlighting and supporting claims by providing complimentary evidence and similar findings. Huangʼs (2005) use of groups interviews highlighted specific areas of interest with direct interaction with audience members, whilst Mascheroniʼs (2008) research adopted ethnographic studies of online, as well as off line interaction in a more one to one manner. Due to the nature of copyright interaction online ethnographic study of users could be applied to researching users of file sharing services. The problem with this is the anonymity in this type of cinteraction, discussed by Watt, Lea and Spears (2002). Although there is potential for some light to be shed on how audiences share music online, it would be difficult to rationalise the reasons for this activity, providing little evidence to illuminate the reader on audience behaviour. My own studies, made use of extensive one on one interviews allowing unsigned artists a mouthpiece within the debate. The benefit of exposing the artists to the one on one interview process was expected to be a greater understanding and experience of copyright yielding technical data on the subject. This was then coupled with group based research. With guidance from Bertrand and Hughes (2005, p81), the group interviews, were expected to benefit from inter-participant discussion allowing some involved to make up in shortfalls of technical knowledge. As a well established means of audience research, group interviews can help garner natural responses from participants. It must always be considered however that these discussions do not take place in unmonitored environments and so must be viewed as having the potential to be polluted by the participants knowledge that what is being said is also being recorded. A particularly pertinent issue given the legal climate surrounding the issues covered. The legal aspect of my research may encourage participants to shy away from full, Robert answers, however the focus group environment should also foster greater candour and less inherently solicited responses than that of one on one interviews for instance (Boubour 2007) although the combination of the two means of study should have a balancing effect on the results. Research Findings Here I present the findings of my primary research investigating the interplay between copyright issues and digital music consumption. The material put forward here is the product of the two group interviews and two individual interviews with consumers and artists respectively. The discussions centred around the same key themes including the participants access to and use of digital music as well as attitudes and understanding of the related legal issues. Of particular importance for my study are responses they may have relevance towards legal the constraints and considerations surrounding the notion of digital music access. Providing the the structural basis of this chapter my aim is to discover any visible Robterns between the responses of the two types of interviewee. Consumption Listening Habits: The primary question for the interviews is one of use and involvement in digital music. It is essential to establish the extent, if any, to which the interview subjects interact with digital music content, irrespective of its origin. The following section examines participant music consumption routines and in particular, digital music consumption habits. Based on their replies, I address the stereotype that older audiences are less willing and able to undertake interaction with new delivery methods whilst isolating comparisons between the groups in other forms of music consumption. On broaching the subject of use of digital music with the older group, it was clear that most participants were involved and responsive to the means of content distribution. Many of the group cited the iPhone or iPod as an influence on their ease of access and enjoyment of digital music, proving Apple have a huge say in how this market is set to develop. either using mp3 players or their mobile phone to consume digital music. When the group was asked if they had access to a digital music player the response was as follows, Howard: Of course Iʼve had mp3 phones for a good 5 years now and players for a bit longer. Dominic: Yeah me too I would say, not the players but the phones, I use an iPhone for everything now. Howard: I still use my player for jogging though, I dont like to be bothered by phone calls but I still want my music with me. Most made some use of access to digital music on a regular basis. This helps to dispel the myth of a generation gap regarding digital media use as alluded to in the work of Mascheroni et al (2008). Although this establishes a commonality in usage of devices we are yet to establish meaningful connections between access and consumption habits. In the older group. The concept of digital music consumption representing the mainstay of their listening habits produced varied responses. For the older group the response was as follows: Dominic: For the car or the house I spose real music, sorry I should say CDs and stuff I spose, real music is normally what I go for. Robert: Yeah the same really. This is similar to the attitudes of both artists interviewed. Biometrix: Yeah its really all about vinyl for me but that normally means I have to rip the vinyl if I want to listen to it on my phone or anything like that Gecko: I collect all sorts of CDs and records, when we go on tour I normally come back with a pile of discs Ive either bought or been given. With the artists and the older audience still actively engaged in the acquisition and collation of music it is clear that there is still a space for tangible products within the music industry. Such observations are notably absent when dealing with the younger of the group studies. In this group there was evidence of a fractured landscape of media access with no commonly held method of consuming music. Youtube, Spotify and Soundcloud provide a number of feels like free options for home use along with the ubiquitous iPod/Phone, however the access to music was overwhelmingly digital amongst this group. It can be said that both groups access digital content in a number of ways, with the younger group being more selective and more aware of different delivery methods, perhaps indicated by the greater disparity in the services and methods of consumption they chose. Within this younger group, extensive different ways of acquiring digital music were referenced, including demonstrable evidence of Leonhardʼs (2008) Ê»feels like freeʼ streaming services such as Spotify and Last.fm. The following extract is taken from the opening stages of the younger focus group; MarT: Spotify, mainly. Youtube too, but there is much less music on there now and when you find something you like it gets deleted after a while for copyright stuff. Spotify have made it so easy and if they have pretty much everything so you can just go there, and if you canʼt find it aint on Spotify there might be a live version or something on Youtube but the quality is always ropey. The only bad thing about Spotify is that you get ads but its still free and its much safer than downloading audio files. Steve: Everything is so joined up on Spotify, like suggested artists and playlists and stuff, I spose its similar on Youtube, you can spend hours exploring. Claire: And you dont have to buy anything or give your card details over. Similarly both artists are avid users of Spotify amongst other streaming services: Gecko: I know the money is peanuts for getting played on there but it makes you accessible to so many people, some of them dont have enough money to pay for your album or your mp3 or whatever but the fact that they can still access it is important to grow as an artist. Its like playing a gig and barely making the petrol money to get home. We all do it but some of us are a bit more relaxed about the good it does for us. Biometrix: I use Spotify all the time, really its stopped me stealing a lot of music really. Its so much easier than actually downloading something so normally I just do that because I cant be bothered finding what I want and then waiting on it to arrive on my computer. Clearly Spotify offers an innovative model that can fit into both of Myškaʼs (2009) subscription service model categories. A monthly fee can be paid to allow listeners to enjoy uninterrupted music without advertising and also allow access to feature rich content such as mobile streaming and offline listening, as well as Leonhards (2009) Ê»feels like freeʼ model that is funded by advertising. Of the myriad methods of media access identified, use of Web 2.0 music consumption models such as Spotify demonstrates a fall in favour of traditional peer to peer networks, contrary to the testaments of the recording industry (Siwek, 2007.) This goes some way to enforce the claims of Leonhard (2009) that these new, lawful access streams provide an attractive alternative to illegal downloading and also allay industry concerns about copyright protection. The interview subjects also cited the simplicity of these new methods in allowing them to locate music without the extensive searching that is commonplace with peer to peer access to media. Engagement with File Sharing: In this section, we assess the subjects involvement with the file sharing. I present rationalisation of the participants use or otherwise of file sharing networks and investigate their understandings and interactions with the legal ramifications of such actions. As the conversation developed, unexpectedly within the older group, many of the participants had used peer to peer services in the past, whilst perhaps their usage was limited, responses seemed mixed. Shaun: Iʼve used Megaupload in the past Yeah. Subscribed to that. We didnt download without our subscription, but now lapsed, I dont about the kids but yeah, Megaupload. I used to et a lot of other stuff there like films and ebooks so it was great. We can see that the participants have an understanding of file sharing as a concept, if not perhaps the finer points of nodal networking. There is an inference that by purchasing a subscription the subject considers themselves to have bought their downloads. This is however false and the subscription simply provides faster download speeds. The artists had a more sophisticated understanding of how rights related to downloading and sharing content, however it is notable that this greater insight did little to dissuade them from partaking in file sharing. Biometrix: Yeah I do download stuff, not as much as I used to but if theres something I cant find on Spotify or Soundcloud or that stuff then I will just go on a torrent site but I feel bad about it, I reckon, well I reckon because I think about what it would be like if the musicians were like me, just starting out or something. The guilt mechanism in this response shows a belief that the RIAA/BPI position is correct and that the copyright issues surrounding this kind of media access is universally illegal. This shows some support for the industry having a direct influence over peoples online interactions despite their diminished market share. One of the artists in particular also uses p2p sharing to promote and distribute their own material. Biometrix: I try to make a couple of free songs every month and put them on soundcloud for people to download. Its pretty much a thanks to all the people on Facebook, Soundcloud and Youtube who like my music and keep my profile hits high. I know theyre on the torrent sites but I dont mind, they were free anyway. This positive use of filesharing allows the artist greater exposure with virtual nil as an overhead, undercutting the top-heavy music industry and presenting the egalitarian model favoured by McLeod (2005). Responses to Legal Issues Industry Implications; This section aims to build on the responses in the previous section by filling out the subjects understanding of the legal issues involved with file sharing. Particularly noticeable in these answers is the difference between the artist and audience categories. As mentioned earlier there have been many examples of litigations against providers of p2p services, such as the media-circus trial of Ê»The Pirate Bayʼ founders. Whilst the audience groups had little knowledge of such cases the artists seemed far better versed in what was going on within the industry to shape the distribution of music. Biometrix: Yeah, Iʼve know a lot about it actually The pirate bay have been found guilty of copyright abuse and theyre appealing their jail term now I think. Its a pretty big deal, all of the big film companies have been after them. The site is still going though, so it doesnt seem to have done much good does it? Gecko: Pirate bay is huge. Its not just pirating things, they do all sorts, politics and freedom of speech stuff and all of that. I think it was started by activists but I dont know whos involved nowadays. As soon as something gets taken off it seems to come straight back up. Loads of people use it. Infringement and theft are put forwards by McLeod as tactics to enforce the monopoly of the recording industry. Of the subjects opinions on the significance file sharing has for the music industry, the various subjects displayed an array of responses. The following extracts are taken from the older subjects; Dominic: Small bands dont have a bean basically. Those are the people you are robbing off, not the execs or anything. Emma: They must be getting paid somehow, the music is still out there. Robert: But the money doesnt go to the band. This passage underlines the fact that members in this group believe that the majority of income for musicians, particularly less prolific artists, is provided by their record sales. This understanding of the revenue streams available to music industries also demonstrates a finely tuned understanding of what the Ê»music industryʼ entails. Williamson and Cloonanʼs (2007) arguments against the wide spread use of the term, based on my findings, suggest older generations are indeed more inclined to understand the term equating to the recording industry. The actions of the recording industries and the responses from audiences can be seen as an example of Michel de Certeauʼs idea of Ê»strategies and tacticsʼ (1984). The strategies of the power structures within the relationship, in this case, the industries retention of traditional retail models and the discourse that it equates to the music industry (BPI, 2009), in contrast to the tactics of audiences. This investigation finds between age demographics the response tactics identifiable and noticably different. The older group creates their own space through a sceptical approach to recording industry practices, methods of media access and opinion demonstrate stronger ties with the recording industry discourse crime and punishment. The both the artists and younger group members seemed much more separated from these established means of operation, shown in their symRobhy for file sharing, anti-corporate comments and reluctance to trust established regulations regarding copyright infringement. Based on the findings outlined above, the suggestion is that audiences are highly aware that there are legal implications surrounding the sharing of files, but their opinions and responses to the validity of these implications are generationally split. The evidence provided by the younger demographic of both audience and artists provides support for the views of McLeod (2005) whereas the older group demonstrated a much more accepting response for the necessity of copyright legislation as a protection against theft. Applying music retail and commerce theories presented by Anderson (2006) and Dubber (2007), most of the participants appeared to be informed of the changes online distribution was experiencing, although there was rejection of the industrys reluctance to develop progressive content access agreements along with them. The divergence of opinion in the application of rights enforcement between the two groups adds weight to the arguments presented by Garofalo (2003), acting to set the balance between the two sides of the rights argument, preventing the financial exploitation of free music, whilst also managing a free channel of access to consumers. Conclusion It can be established from the results of my investigation that audience and artist opinions are divided on the justifications for rights protection and the enforcement thereof in relation to digital music access. Whilst there is clear evidence of a move towards digital media consumption, there is a distinct generational gap in the manner in which different age groups access music digitally. Older generations seem to fall into line with traditional models of product capitalisation, purchasing physical formats and viewing transgression of copyright online as theft. Younger subjects more immersed in digital media and having grown up during the internet gold rush have a far less strict attitude to the acquisit
|
Categories |